Go / No-Go Decision: the full explanation
Published: · Updated: · By: Son Yaklaşma editorial team
What is the go/no-go decision?
Before every flight, the pilot in command decides whether the weather will remain within the limits of the aircraft, themselves and the rules throughout the flight. This is called the pre-flight go/no-go decision. For a VFR flight the decision rests largely on three questions: is the weather at departure above VFR minima, what will the weather be at the destination at the estimated time of arrival (ETA), and is there a suitable alternate if things go wrong?
The answers to these questions are in the METAR and TAF. The METAR is the current observation and gives roughly a one-hour picture; the TAF is a forecast for the next 9–30 hours. For planning, the current METAR is used for departure and the TAF covering the destination and alternate ETA is used.
VFR minima
| Situation | Surface visibility | Ceiling |
|---|---|---|
| VFR (SERA.5001, controlled aerodrome) | 5 km | 1500 ft |
| Typical school solo student minimum | 8 km | 2500 ft |
| Outside control zone, below 3000 ft (SERA) | 5 km (up to 1500 m permitted when speed ≤140 kt) | cloud-free, ground visible |
Flight schools and operators often set stricter minima, especially for solo student flights. In the simulation you can select "School, solo student" or a custom minimum to see how the same weather leads to different decisions.
How are TAF groups interpreted?
| Group | Meaning | In planning |
|---|---|---|
BECMG 2709/2711 9999 | The change occurs at any time between 09 and 11; permanent after 11. | Use the worse value during the period; use the new value once the period ends. |
TEMPO 2712/2716 3000 TSRA | Temporary fluctuations; each lasting under 1 hour, total less than half the period. | If the ETA is within this period and the value is below minima, a suitable alternate is essential. |
PROB40 2715/2718 2000 BR | This condition occurs with 40% probability. | If below minima, treat it like TEMPO: alternate required. |
PROB30 TEMPO 2715/2718 TSRA | Temporary condition with 30% probability. | Note it and keep your alternate plan ready; not a reason to cancel on its own. |
FM271400 25015KT 9999 SCT030 | Completely new forecast from 14:00. | After FM, all previous values are no longer valid. |
Crosswind and aircraft limit
The demonstrated crosswind stated in the aircraft's handbook (POH/AFM) is the highest crosswind in which test pilots landed safely. It is considered the practical upper limit for students and low-experience pilots. In the calculation, the wind is converted to magnetic, the runway most nearly into the wind is selected, and the crosswind component including gusts is compared with the limit. For example, in a 250° 14G20 kt wind, the crosswind component on runway 31 is about 18 kt: suitable for a DA20 with a 20 kt limit, but not for a C172 with a 15 kt limit.
Daylight
A PPL pilot without night rating must complete the flight before official sunset. As good practice, plan to arrive at least 15 minutes before sunset; wind, holding or go-arounds quickly use up this margin.
Worked example
Bursa Yenisehir (LTBR) → Corlu (LTBU), planned departure 06:00 UTC. LTBR METAR: 00000KT 0300 FG VV001, TAF: BECMG 2706/2707 5000 BR BKN006 BECMG 2707/2708 9999 SCT025. At 06:00 visibility is 300 m and vertical visibility 100 ft: below minima, do not depart. At 07:00 visibility is 5 km but ceiling 600 ft: still below minima. After 08:00 it is 9999 and SCT025, no ceiling: suitable. At LTBU there is TEMPO 06–08 4000 BR, but with a 08:00 departure the ETA is about 08:55, the period has ended. Correct decision: delay 2 hours.
Common mistakes
- Only looking at the METAR. The weather at departure may be good, but at the ETA the destination may have TEMPO thunderstorms or fog.
- Ignoring TEMPO. "Temporary" does not mean "insignificant"; if below minima, an alternate is essential.
- Choosing an alternate without checking the weather. The alternate must also be above minima at the ETA.
- Not accounting for gusts. In a 14G20 kt wind, calculate the crosswind component with 20, not 14.
- Racing sunset. Without night rating, leave a margin; last-minute departures are the riskiest.
How is the VFR go/no-go decision made?
- Set the route and ETA. Select the departure, destination and alternate aerodromes; calculate the estimated time of arrival from distance and cruise speed.
- Check the departure weather. In the current METAR, are visibility and ceiling above minima, and is the crosswind within the aircraft's limit?
- Read the destination TAF for your ETA. Evaluate the main forecast covering the ETA, and the BECMG, TEMPO and PROB groups, separately.
- Select alternate aerodrome. If there is a TEMPO/PROB40 risk at arrival, choose an alternate aerodrome with a margin above minimums at the ETA.
- Check daylight. If you do not hold a night rating, make sure arrival is well before sunset.
- Make a decision. If all conditions are suitable, go; if not now but soon, delay; if not, do not go.
Frequently asked questions
What are the minimum visibility and ceiling for VFR flight?
At a controlled aerodrome (control zone), for VFR take-off and landing, generally at least 5 km ground visibility and a 1500 ft ceiling are required (SERA.5001, SERA.5005). Flight schools apply stricter minima for student flights.
What does TEMPO mean in a TAF, and does it prevent flight?
TEMPO indicates temporary fluctuations, each lasting less than 1 hour, during the stated period. If the ETA falls within this period and the TEMPO values are below minimums, the flight may only depart with a suitable alternate aerodrome.
What is the difference between BECMG and TEMPO?
BECMG is a change that begins at any point in the period and then persists; TEMPO is a temporary fluctuation, and the main forecast resumes at the end of the period.
How are PROB30 and PROB40 assessed?
PROB refers to conditions with a 30% or 40% probability. In this simulation, if PROB40 is below minima, it requires an alternate like TEMPO; PROB30 is noted and the alternate plan is kept ready.
What is demonstrated crosswind?
This is the highest crosswind component in which safe take-off and landing have been demonstrated during the aircraft's certification tests. It is not a structural limit, but it is considered a practical upper limit for student pilots.
Is gust taken into account when calculating crosswind?
Yes. To stay on the safe side, the crosswind component is calculated with manoeuvring speed. In a 14G20 kt wind, the crosswind component is found from 20 kt.
How do you choose an alternate aerodrome?
An alternate should have a forecast above minima at the ETA, suitable crosswind and be reachable with the fuel carried. An aerodrome close enough to experience the same bad weather at the destination is not a good alternate.
Can this simulation be used in real flight?
No. It is for training purposes and the rules are simplified. In real flight, the official meteorological briefing, NOTAM, the aircraft's POH/AFM, and the school's or operator's minima apply.
Sources
- SERA (EU 923/2012): SERA.5001 VMC visibility and cloud distance minima, SERA.5005 VFR
- EASA Air Ops, Part-NCO: NCO.OP.160 meteorological conditions
- WMO No. 49 / ICAO Annex 3: TAF change indicators (BECMG, TEMPO, PROB, FM)
- FAA, Pilot's Handbook of Aeronautical Knowledge: aeronautical decision-making